Family Line Links: (WikiTree.com)(Ancestry.com)(FamilySearch.org)
The Reeves surname is English in origin, and likely derives from the occupational title given to someone who was the steward or bailiff for a Lord's property holdings. In older spellings, it is sometimes given as Ryves or Rives. There are many different lines of Reeves that came to America in the 1600-1700s, and sorting them all out has been an ongoing project of the Reeves DNA Project at FamilyTreeDNA. My line's DNA signature matches with what they have labeled DNA Group 10, which traces back to a man named George Reeves who was born in Virginia in about 1696, and who was likely of Welsh decent.
By 1789, northern KY settlers were arriving at the shores of Limestone (now Maysville) at a rate of 30 flatboats per day (Ref 18, p.78). As new areas of the West were surveyed, new homesteaders often built their properties near a defensive residence, called a "Station", to which the residents could flee if danger arose from Indian attacks (Ref 17). Settler families would often live in these stations while building their new homes. In Mason Co., the first of these stations was built in 1784 by Simon Kenton, a few miles west of the town of Old Washington today (now considered part of Maysville). Settlement spread slowly southward from Limestone, and by 1787, Major George Stockton was building a station in current day Flemingsburg. There is a good chance that this is where the Reeves family stayed while building their new cabin home (Note 12).
2) All that is actually known for certain is that at the same time the previously discussed Thomas Reeves disappeared in the records of Lancaster Co., VA, a Thomas Reeves of similar age suddenly showed up in Richmond Co., VA records, and so they are assumed to be the same person. (Ref 1)
3) This also is still uncertain. At about the same time the Thomas Reeves of Richmond Co., VA disappears from records (1723), another Thomas Reeves begins to appear in Northumberland Co. records. However, it may be that Thomas Reeves actually stayed in Richmond Co. after all and simply died by 1723, and that the Northumberland Co. Thomas Reeves was instead his son, Thomas Jr. (b.1700), who would have come of age at about this time.
However, the Northumberland Co. Thomas died by 1729, and when his daughter Hannah was baptized there in 1714, Thomas, Jr. would have still been quite young to be a father. It is my assumption then that Thomas Reeves, Sr. did move to Northumberland by 1714, and this was likely also the same Thomas Reeves who died there in 1729. There is, however, the matter of Thomas Reeves Will, which was administered in 1729 by a William and Margaret Scurlock. It has been suggested that this implies that Margaret Scurlock was likely Thomas Reeves re-married widow. I have seen this Scurlock family name show up a few times in some of my early Reeves line, however, so I think there are possibilities that could explain this, and for now it seems most likely to me that they are the same person, not father and son.
4) Dowager rights (often referred to as the Widow's Third) were a way of protecting widows in Colonial America from financial ruin in the event that their husband died first. Although it did not allow the widow to actually own property, which would have interfered with the inheritance rights of male offspring, it did allow them 1/3 interest in the land's use and profits until they died or relinquished that right. Usually, when an "estate in dower" was later sold by the heir, a widow that was still living would relinquish her dowager rights as part of the deal, though not always. And if she did not, she was still entitled to her portion of the land's interests. In some places, this 1/3 interest terminated if the widow remarried, but in others it simply passed to her new husband instead, which seems to have been the case in Lancaster Co., VA during this time period.
5) The Will of Conway refers to land "now in the possession of George Reeves, with all the lower part of the neck as far as the mouth of “Long Neck Branch,” thence with a straight line to the mouth of “Gayner Branch"". It is assumed that this Gayners branch refers to what is known today as Garners Creek, which lies within Cherry Point Neck (possibly the Long Neck he refers to?) and which then made up the northwestern part of St. Stephen's Parish. This parish often gets attention due to it being the parish of President George Washington's great-grandfather, and also his uncle, Col. James Ball.
6) Tobacco was a very labor-intensive crop, and as indentured servants became more successful at securing their labor rights, and land rights after indenture became scarcer to acquire, profit seeking colonists began to turn instead to slave labor. Carter worked as an agent to facilitate this slave trade as well. My Thomas Reeves certainly worked alongside black slaves while he was indentured in Lancaster Co. However, the only Reeves of this line known to have owned slaves for certain is George's brother John (b.1713) and John's son Benjamin (b. 1721). Later members of the family line seemed very opposed to the practice slavery. Perhaps having been indentured unwillingly himself gave Thomas a sour taste for its workings.
7) Three of George Reeves, Sr's. presumed children were not included in the 1751 deed gift: Thomas, Reuben, and George, Jr. All 3 of these children would have reached 21 years of age before or in 1751, and so perhaps their father had previously provided for them in some way by this point. On the 1747 Tithable List, George Jr., Benjamin, Reuben, and Thomas were all listed as between the age of 16-21. His father George Sr., as well as his uncle John Sr., and also John Sr.'s son George Jr., (of similar age) were listed as well (ie there were 3 different George Reeves listed on the 1747 Tithables List, 2 of whom were aged 16-21)(Ref 9, pp.160-165).
On the PWC Rent Rolls of 1753, after the 1751 land gift to his children, Benjamin and John Jr. (who has just come of age) now show up as well (Moses and Asa are still minors), but Thomas, Reuben, and George Jr. are now missing. Thomas may have been exempt from taxes due to working as a slave patroller, as was stated on the 1765 tax list. Reuben is no longer mentioned in any records after 1753, and is presumed to have died sometime that year.
A George Reeves Jr. is still repeatedly found listed in later records, however, but from 1751 onward there is only one of them, and from 1751-1754 there is also a Grace Reeves who suddenly appears living nearby them, presumably a widow. The 1762 Rent Rolls specifically mention this George Jr. as being the son of John Reeves (George Sr.'s brother), and the description of this George's land holdings from 1760-1777 suggest this to be the same George across all of those years. Thus, I have assumed here that George Reeves Sr.'s son George Jr. died by 1751, that Grace Reeves was his widow, and that the George Reeves still present was his cousin instead.
George Sr.'s Feb 1774 Will is no longer extant, and so unfortunately cannot be used to further verify this. As the oldest, Thomas likely inherited his father's main homestead after his death, but he had moved to SC/GA by 1784. Benjamin also had moved to Halifax Co., VA by 1762.
8) Originally, the Overwharton parish (Ref. 9, p.197) served the entire county of Stafford as it existed in that time (much larger than today), and in 1726 it was led by Rev. Alexander Scott (who also rectored for the nearby St. Paul parish) near his Dipple estate in Stafford (town), VA. A chapel of ease was built for this parish in Dumfries as early as 1667 and called the Quantico Church. In 1730, when Prince William County was formed from part of Stafford county, the Overwharton parish was divided as well, with the NW part (where the Reeves' were) forming the new Hamilton parish (Ref 9, p.216). The official Hamilton parish chapel was located at Elk Eun in what would become Fauquier Co. by 1745. With this new county formation, Hamilton Parish split again, this time, creating the Dettingen parish in the area of Prince William Co. today. Dettingen parish was served by Rev. James Scott, the younger brother of Rev. Alexander Scott, both from Scotland (Ref 9, p.207).
9) Though the northern part of what is now Lancaster Co., SC was settled mainly by German and Scotch-Irish Baptists from Pennsylvania and Maryland, the southern part of the county after 1760 was settled by Welsh immigrants. This is notable because Asa Reeves Sr.'s adopted son Benjamin Reeves (who is assumed to have been a relation of some sort) had a son named Benjamin F. Reeves that wrote a biography which described the family as being of Welsh descent (Ref 15).
10) Asa Reeves Sr.'s Will of 1819 bequeaths land to all of his natural born sons, but also makes reference to the fact that most of them have already chosen to sell that bequeathment. In fact, he mentions that the land he is bequeathing to his son Asa Jr. is the same tract that was previously bequeathed to his son William Reeves, but then purchased back by Asa Sr. when he moved away. When Isaac moved away in 1825, he sold his land back to his brother George. In fact, the only male offspring to stick around for the long-term was his son George Reeves (b.1786), who died there in about 1841. This land was resurveyed at his death for his widow Nancy (Hiday/Hayden) Reeves. It is described as "including the mansion house lying on the waters of poplar run in sd. county containing seventy-five acres and bounded as follows Beginning...Wm. W. Blair corner, on James Ewings line" (Fleming County, Kentucky Will Records Vol. G, p. 152). Earlier nearby land records also mention the Reeves land in this area, which was adjacent to a 10,000-acre land patent to Major John Mosby (part of a 30,000-acre grant in 1785). Also, in 1799, William and Eli Reeves were ordered to mark out the "best way for a road from Flemingsburg to the mouth of the Fleming" (Fleming County, Kentucky Court Order Book A, 1798-1802).
11) Asa Reeves Sr.'s nephew, Elijah Sr. (descended through Thomas (b.1670)->George Sr.->Thomas->Elijah Sr. (b.1740)), had set off for Kentucky by 1786 (Ref. 18, p.56), and this no doubt this played a role in my Reeves line KY migration as well. His family seems to have settled in the SE part of what became Fleming Co., near Hillsboro today, and his son Spencer married Asa's daughter Susannah.
12) Asa Reeves sold his land in Aug of 1789, and likely spent the better part of a month traveling Braddock's Road to Pittsburg and then another month floating the Ohio River west to Limestone. By the time he would have arrived in late November, there would not have been time to build a home before the winter set in. Depending on the timing, perhaps the family even stayed at Fort Pitt that first winter and set off for Limestone first thing the following spring. It is known that he was definitely living in KY by the Aug 1790 census, however.
There were only 3 Stations in Flemings Co. by 1790: Stockton's in north Flemingsburg, - probably completed by 1788, as well as Fleming's Station (just south of Flemingsburg near Martha Mills Rd) (Ref. 19, p.199) and Cassidy's Station (just west of Flemingsburg), these last two were both started about 1788, but were not completed until 1790. While these last 2 Stations would have been a couple miles closer to the Reeves land than Stockton's Station, they likely would not have been ready for guests by then, and Flemings Station in particular may never have actually even been lived in (See John Fleming Jr. - WikiTree Profile).
13) Eli Reeves sold a part of his land in 1818 to James Beard (Brown County, Ohio Deed Book A1, p147) which was described as "situate[d] on the waters of Eagle Creek at or near the Indian Lick". According to a cemetery survey taken in 1963 by a Mrs. Ann Johnson, his grave marker is "located on Laura Chapman's farm East of Red Oak, off Mt. Aire Road, off Hermann Road, back a lane". (Note that this is not the same as the Chapman Cemetery in Higginsport listed on FindAGrave). This portion of Indian Lick is in Byrd Twp, which matches the residence of Eli Reeves on the 1820 census. Additionally, the 1876 Atlas published by Lake, Griffing, and Stevenson Byrd, Atlas: Brown County 1876, Ohio Historical Map (historicmapworks.com) shows 2 Reeves families living just east of this area on W. Eagle Creek, one of whom may be Eli's son, John Wilson Reeves.
14) This family really liked various versions of the name Eli, which can be pretty confusing. Elias "Eli" Reeves (b. 1769) had 3 different sons with variations on this theme, including Ila (his oldest son, said to go by "Iley"), Eli (b.1796), and Elijah (his youngest son, b.1814). Complicating matters is their cousin Elijah Reeves (b.1740), who also lived Fleming Co., KY, though in the SE portion of the county off Rock Lick Creek. This Elijah had a son named Elijah as well of course (b.1781), although this second line seems to have remained in Fleming Co., until eventually removing to IL around 1830.
15) There was an Eli Reeves that fought in Mississippi during the War of 1812, but he seems to be from an unrelated Reeves line of Pike Co., MS. Of note, Eli Reeves, Sr. (b.1769) is often mentioned in articles as having served in the Revolutionary War, though I have never found any actual evidence of this. It may be that people are confusing him with his older brother Ila who was in the war. Eli though would have been only 6 years old when it started, and 14 when it ended, which was too young to enlist as a soldier. Although boys as young as 9 years of age did sometimes serve as drummer boys or messengers, which still entitled them to land grants, I cannot find records for this in his case. The story though, is that he did receive a military claim for his land in OH, but "failing in some way to lay it properly, lost the title to his land and was obliged to purchase another place from the government."
I think what is more likely is that he performed some less official role during the war effort, one that did not entitle him to land. Perhaps it was by helping to clear roads for tactical troop relocations, as younger boys were sometimes called on to assist with, or by simply helping his father Asa to deliver needed troop supplies. Certainly, the war effort was a family affair that required extra responsibilities from all present.
16) Slavery was one of the main social structures under scrutiny during the Second Great Awakening in America. Differences of opinion within the Methodist church during this time resulted in a number of factions forming. Many anti-slavery Methodists from KY, like John Rankin, felt their beliefs and values were being oppressed by the culture around them, and sought refuge instead in slavery-free Ohio. Though I have found no direct evidence yet that the Reeves were abolitionists themselves, indirect evidence of their religious persuasions points in that direction.
17) Land records show that Iley, Daniel, and Jabez all purchased land in Indiana 1827-8. According to "Biographical Memoirs of Hancock County" (Ref 24), as a widow, Sarah (Redmon) Reeves "accompanied some of her children to Indiana". This reference also states that her son Elijah Reeves "began life for himself" at 15 years of age, which would seem to correspond to the 1828 departure of much of his family. Based on census records, Sarah seems to have lived with her son Jabez until she passed in 1844.
18) I cannot find my Elijah Reeves (b.1832) in any 1850 census records, including those of his relatives living in Indiana. There is an Elijah C. Reeves of similar age in his uncle Neville Reeves home, but this is clearly his son, not his nephew. There are also a few unconnected Elijah Reeves from the Fleming, KY branch of the family. Given that my Elijah later married in Brown Co., OH, and that both his oldest and youngest brothers seem to have remained in Brown Co., OH after their mother's death, I am assuming that was the case for him as well. I have also not been able to find any additional information for the 2 sons and 1 daughter that were listed as < 5 on the 1840 census. If you have any information on these "forgotten" siblings, I would love to hear from you!
19) The typed copies of enlisted records state the location as Lebanon, PA, but the handwritten copies list Lebanon, OH, which makes much more sense.
References
1) The Reeves Project : A global genealogical collaboration. "Family of George Reeves", (ID:202). https://thereevesproject.org/data/tiki-index.php?page=Reeve_George_202&structure=FamilyOf_Reeve_George_202 : accessed 2024.
2) Will of Charles Dodson, written Jan 11, 1702: Richmond County, Virginia, Will Book 2, pp. 95-96; https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-C9PF-CSBJ-C.
3) Doggett, J.D. Doggetts and other cousins : 100benjamin (doggettfam.org), (2005) : accessed 2024.6) Northern Neck Virginia Land Grants, Vol, 1, Book B, p.86, record B-86. https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/49389/?name=George_Reeves&count=50 : accessed 17 July 2024.
12) Deed to John Reeves. Prince William Co., VA Deed Book A p.181-183. (19 Apr 1732) The Reeves Project : 2024.
13) Deed to Thomas Davis. Prince William Co., VA Deed Book A, p. 137-138. (17 Nov 1731) The Reeves Project : 2024.
15) Evans, Madison. "Biographical sketches of the pioneer preachers of Indiana", p.374. Philadelphia, J. Challen & Sons : IN, 1862. https://archive.org/details/biographicalske00evangoog/page/n483/mode/2up
16) Axton, W. F. "Tobacco and Kentucky", Chap. 2. University Press of KY. (1975). Internet Archive. https://archive.org/details/tobaccokentucky0000axto/page/24/mode/2up
18) Clift, G. G. "History of Maysville and Mason County". Vol. 1. Transylvania Printing Co. : Lexington, KY, 1936. HathiTrust. https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=hvd.hxbx2y&seq=131&q1=Reeves
20) Bowen, B. F. "Biographical Memoirs of Hancock County". Logansport, IN : 1902. Transcribed by Sylvia (Rose) Duda : 2024.
21) Evans, N. W. "A history of Adams County, Ohio, from its earliest settlement to the present time, including character sketches of the prominent persons identified with the first century of the country’s growth". (1900). Internet Archive. https://archive.org/details/ahistoryadamsco01stivgoog/page/34/mode/2up?view=theater
22) "The history of Brown County, Ohio : containing a history of the county, its townships, towns, churches, schools, etc., general and local statistics, portraits of early settlers and prominent men, history of the Northwest territory, history of Ohio, map of Brown County, Constitution of the United States, miscellaneous matters, etc., etc." Chicago, IL : W.H. Beers & Co. (1883). Internet Archive. https://archive.org/details/bub_gb_udUyAQAAMAAJ/page/693/mode/2up?view=theater