The Enyeart's: Family Ties in an Early Pennsylvania Rural Community

Every once in a while in my genealogy research, I come across a family that surprises me for one reason or another. While researching our Dean/Norris lines of the Raystown Branch Juniata River in PA, I came across one such family - the Enyeart's. I kept finding myself thinking about them so often that I finally decided I just had to write something.

Raystown Branch Juniata River, Huntingdon County, PA

In my prior post on the Dean's, I mentioned a rivalry that existed between the Deans and Norrises, who lived on neighboring farms near the boarder of Juniata and Penn townships (then Hopewell Twp.) Years later this quarrel seems to have been adequately resolved, as evidenced by the marriage between Abraham Dean (b.1837) and Hannah Norris (b.1842). Like Abraham's great grandfather John Dean (b.1739) discussed previously, Hannah's great grandfather Joseph P. Norris, Sr. (b.1729) also came to Huntingdon County, PA from Frederick Co., MD (now Washington Co.) around the time of the Revolutionary War. Joseph P. Norris, Sr. had a son named Joseph P. Norris, Jr. (b. 1774), who is also in our direct line. And this Joseph married Elizabeth "Betsey" Enyeart (b.1779) in 1797.

Elizabeth Enyeart came from the very large family of William Enyeart (b.1748), another early settler of the Raystown Branch Juniata River (Ref 2, p.75). He was from NJ originally, but married his first wife, Catherine Schell (b.1750, our direct line) in Frederick Co., MD. He then went on to have 23 kids! Can you imagine??!? Not that many couples didn't have fairly large families at that time, but even a large family usually topped out around 15 kids, and around 10 was more typical. I'm not certain that he has the largest family of our tree so far, but he's definitely in the upper 1%. And due to the large number of healthy offspring he had, his family line ended up linking a lot of the early Juniata River Valley families together through marriage, including our own. With quite a few twists and turns along the way.

Outline of Juniata Twp. shown in red. Penn Twp. is at its southern border, while Walker Twp. lies to its west and Union Twp. to its east.

William Enyeart was well regarded by his community (Ref 3, p.1181). He was said to be famous for his excellent shooting abilities, which allowed his large family to never go hungry. While his main occupation was farming, he was also a part-time blacksmith (Ref 5, p.6). He was a soldier in the Bedford Co. Pennsylvania Militia during the Revolutionary War, and played a prominent role in establishing the early Huntingdon Co. government, in which he served as an auditor. He also was a regular member of the Protestant Episcopal Church and a large land owner in the area.

Raystown Branch Juniata River showing outline of pre-dam river boundaries. Homestead location is approximate.

He and his first wife Catherine (Shell) married in 1772 when they were 24 and 22 years of age respectively. By 1780 they had 4 children, despite Willian presumably being away for significant periods of time during his years of military service (1778-1783). His 4th child, Elizabeth (our direct ancestor), was born in March 1779. Perhaps his stretches of time away did impact the young couple eventually though, for after the birth of Elizabeth, there is and unexpected gap in the birth record until their 5th child, David, was born in May 1787. Only 10 month later they were poised to welcome their next offspring, this time twins, when tragedy struck. Catherine died in childbirth on Mar 20, 1788, along with her two infant girls. She and the twins were buried at the Yocum family cemetery, their neighbors upriver to the south.

At this point William was 39 years old, and the single father of 5 children ranging in age from 1 to 14 years of age. Fortunately for him, another upriver neighbor, Joseph P. Norris, was able to assist. His daughter Jane Norris was sent to help manage the household. Joseph was a second generation American of Scotch-Irish descent, and the father of 12 children himself (see Note 1), but by 1788, all but his youngest two children had either married or passed on. His daughter, Jane (b.1772), was but 15 years old, which was quite a bit younger than typical for marriage at that time. Nevertheless, she turned 16 that Aug, and in Sept. she and William married just after he turned 40. Even more awkward, her eldest step-child, John, was only 2 years younger than she was! Granted, marrying a younger second wife was not all that uncommon in this time period, though a difference in age of at most about 10-15 years was much more typical. William was a reasonably wealthy and respected man, however, and was probably considered a "good catch".

Jane (Norris) was of healthy, fertile stock, and within 10 months, had added another child, James, to the mix. Over the next 5 years she birthed 5 more children, and then in Sep 1797, she gave birth to boy/girl twins, Benjamin and Jane, this time healthy and strong. So Jane was now the 25 year old mother/step-mother of 12 kids! Thankfully, their home was a bit larger than typical houses of those days (Ref. 5, p.6). In 1782, William had built the family a large, 2.5 story, 10 room stone home, for which he crafted each nail or other piece of hardware by his own two hands. The rooms were cleverly partitioned by folding doors such that all the rooms on each floor could be opened to create one large room if desired. And it was built nestled into the mountainside overlooking the Juniata River Valley. 

Remains on the Enyeart stone house, photographed by Mary Enyeart Racer circa 1910 (pre-dam).

On the marriage front, William's neighbor Joseph Norris, Sr. was still willing to deal. He had one last child to marry off, Jane's younger brother Joseph, Jr. It is unclear why the Enyeart's older daughter Mary was passed over for this union. It is also uncertain why Elizabeth married so early compared to her other siblings. Was there some type of agreement made between the two fathers at the time of the first marriage? Or maybe she didn't get along with her step-mother? Regardless, in 1797, at 18 years of age, William's second daughter, Elizabeth, was willing to tie the knot. That's right, our direct ancestor, Elizabeth, married her step-mom's 23 year old brother! They settled nearby and went on to eventually have a family of 11 children themselves.

Over the next 10 years, no other Enyeart children married, and Jane went on to birth 5 more children, increasing their household size to 18 occupants by 1806. Luckily for these two busy parents, the family size would finally begin to decrease at this point. For although there were still 4 children to be born, there were also now a number of children of (typical) marriable age. But where to find partners for all these offspring in such a rural area? Even today, Juniata township has only about 20 people per square mile, and the population back then was about 25% of what it is today. Answer - you look to your neighbors, and sometimes you take a 2 (or even 3) for 1 bargain! Or, you move on to the greener pastures of newly opening territories like OH and IN.

Approximate locations of neighboring families (see Note 2)

The 16 children of William Enyeart, Sr. & Jane (Norris)

In 1807, William Enyeart, Sr.'s second oldest son, William, Jr., and his oldest daughter, Mary, both married. Mary married Isaac Vandevender, son of Peter Vandevender from Holland (Ref 1, p.218), who owned a distillery/inn near Mapleton where the railroad would one day cross the Juniata River. Mary and Isaac settled in McConnellstown, PA. William, Jr. was one of only two male offspring of William Enyeart, Sr. who stayed in PA (the other being David). Most of the males relocated to newly established Miami Co., OH starting in the 1820s (see Note 3), and later to Wabash Co., IN. But William Enyeart, Jr. stayed and married Elizabeth Wilson, daughter of Thomas Wilson (Ref 1, p.336). Thomas was an Englishman who built the first grist mill in the area for grinding grains. Ten years later, Jane (Norris) Enyeart's daughter Jane would also marry a son from this family.

1875 drawing by Sipes depicting view of the railroad eastward from Mapleton, PA

John Enyeart, William, Sr.'s eldest son, seems to have been the first offspring to move westward to Miami Co., OH (see Note 4) where he married a woman named Mary Kessler in 1809. They had only 1 child, a girl named Mary. Then, in 1810, William and Jane's 4th son, James, married downriver neighbor Sarah Kisling. Sarah Kisling's father, Martin Kisling, was a second generation German immigrant (Ref 6, p.119, Ref 1, p.303) whose family had originally settled in Berks Co., PA. They were relative newcomers to Huntingdon Co., having only arrived in 1791, well after the end of the war. Three years later, William's son, Silas, married another Kisling daughter, Hannah. Both couples relocated to Miami Co, OH between 1815-1825.

The trek from Juniata Twp, Huntingdon Co., PA to Miami Co., OH was 388 miles. From Miami Co. to Wabash Co., IN added another 134 miles.

In 1812, William's 3rd oldest son, David, married Margaret Householder. The Householders (from the German line Haushalter) seem to have been closely tied to the Vanderventers, and served together in the War of 1812 (see Note 5). David was the last of the Enyeart males to stay in PA rather than moving on to OH or IN. He was also the last of the children from William's first marriage to tie the knot, so by 1813 only Jane's children remained. It was still a full house, but Jane's birth rate slowed after her daughter Rebecca was born in 1808. She still somehow went on to have 3 more children in her 40's, but her next child, Margaret, wasn't born until 1814, by which point the household size had time to whittle down to 14.

By 1816, their son Joseph set off for OH as well, and married a woman there named Margaret Wickard. Then, in 1817, Benjamin married Judith Lloyd. Judith was the granddaughter of Henry Lloyd, Sr. (Ref 1, p.379), one of the very earliest settlers of the valley, and one who had lived through many Native American raids in Huntingdon County's early founding. His family was originally from VA, and had immigrated from Wales before that. Judith and Benjamin initially settled in neighboring Blair Co., PA to begin their family. At this point, William and Jane had successfully married off 10 children, but there were still so many to go! It was time to get serious about this.

Luckily, the Enyearts were also close with their neighbors to the north, the Heffners (Ref 7, p.180, Ref 1, p.380). Originally of German descent, Valentine Heffner had also fought in the Revolutionary War, and then filed for his bounty land warrant in PA. In 1818, he had a son named Peter that was of the right age to enter into marriage with William's daughter Catherine Enyeart. They decided to make it a twofer though, and the following year, William's daughter Rachel married a Heffner son as well - John. A few years later (1824), the families joined hands once again, and at age 16, William's daughter Rebecca married Valentine's youngest son Adam, age 25. Meanwhile, William's son Thomas also left for OH, where he married Mary Berk in 1819. Unlike his siblings, who were all settling near one another in Miami Co., OH, Thomas went off on his own to settle in Butler Co., OH.  Likely this was due to the trouble he got himself into in 1815, when he had a child out of wedlock with his neighbor to the south, Elizabeth Beaver. Luckily for Elizabeth, she was still able to find a husband about a year and a half later, and went on to have a legitimate family of her own.

In 1820, William Enyeart arranged another double match, this time with the children of his downstream neighbor William Corbin. Mr. Corbin, originally from MD, has served as a Ranger on the PA frontier alongside William Enyeart during the war (Ref 1, p.302). Corbin was on the tail end of marrying off the last of his own offspring at that point, and was willing to do another twofer. First, his 24 year old son David married Nancy Ann Enyeart, who was only 16 at the time. They settled on the Corbin property and carried on the Corbin family line there for many generations. A year later, in 1821, a "sister swap" marriage occurred when Levi Enyeart, only 19, which was quite young for a male, married William Corbin's youngest child, Sophia, who was 23. Why they didn't pair the two couples of closer age together instead is a bit of a mystery. Offspring preference one would hope? Regardless, these two marriages would have reduced the Enyeart household size to 8 persons, if it weren't for the fact that in 1820, William, Jr's house was repossessed for failure to make payments, and he had to move his family of 5 back into his parents house (Ref 8, Note 6).

Jane birthed her last child, Elenor, in 1821, at the age of 49! Which while not impossible, is definitely rare. Women usually had their last child by their early 40s. I would be tempted to assume it was really a grandchild, but when William Enyeart, Sr. wrote his will in Jun of 1828, he mentioned Elenor by name as his child (Ref 9). Jane, and even more so, William, Sr., were getting old themselves at this point. The younger age of their children in these last few marriages was likely an effort to secure their children's futures before William died. By 1824, when Jane was 52 and William Sr. was 76, five of their children were still at home, ranging in age from 3 to 18 years. Likely William Jr. and his family were still living there as well, and they had 4 living children of their own by this time.  

In 1824, William's 4th youngest daughter, Sarah, married William Masden, the son of Johnathan Masden. It has been difficult to find out much about this family (see Note 7). They were from neighboring Mifflin Co. rather than Huntingdon Co. originally. Johnathan Masden seems to have died only 2 years after his son William was married, and his offspring all seem to have left PA for OH in the decade after. The Enyearts must have been quite close to the family though. For not only did William Sr. and Jane (Norris) Enyeart's daughter Sarah marry into the family, but their daughter Elizabeth (the one who married her step-mom's brother, our direct ancestor) had 3 of 11 children who also married into it! (As well as 3 who married into the neighboring Grubb family).  

In 1825, William's daughter Martha married John McMonigal from nearby Baree Twp. They initially settled in that township after the marriage, but eventually moved to Indiana. Martha would be the last of his children that William would see married before his death in 1828. He died Sept 2, 1828. Now it was up to Jane to finish raising their 3 remaining children - Margaret (age 14), Abraham (age 11), and Elenor (age 7). Faced with this predicament, Jane decided to move her family to Miami Co., OH where most of her adult children had relocated to by this time. William Jr.'s family stayed behind and assumed control of the farm, though he would die as well only 3 years later, at the age of 53. Jane's adult son Benjamin chose to join his mother on her trek west. To do so, he divorced his wife Judith Lloyd (very rare at that time) and left his 7 children in PA. Within a year he had remarried to Sarah Mustard and started a new family in OH. Eventually he had 10 more kids!

The 1830 census shows Jane living independently with her 3 remaining children in Staunton, Miami Co., OH. In 1834, her daughter Margaret married Jacob Graffius, son of Martin Graffius and grandson of Nicholas Graffius, who had come to Huntingdon Co. after the Revolutionary War. The family was of French Huguenots descent, having originally come to America in the 1750s due to religious persecution (Ref 7, p.229). Martin was a farmer of both crops and stock animals, as well as a distiller. He came from a large and well respected family in the area. His son Jacob relocated to Miami Co., OH after marrying Margaret. 

The 1820-30's were an exciting time in early America due to canal construction. Completion of canals linked together major cities and vastly decreased the cost of shipping goods from one area to another. It created new and far easier ways for settlers to expand into the western territories (Ref 10). It also likely explains why most of the Enyeart's who settled in Miami Co., OH near Troy, began to gradually relocate to Wabash Co., IN near Lagro, beginning in about 1838. The Miami extension of the Erie canal, which went through Troy, was started in 1834 and reached Lagro in 1837. A wave of new settlement soon followed, and for many years Lagro was a prosperous and widely known town (Ref 11).

Postcard image created by Terry Lacy depicting the Kerr Lock in mid-1800s

Erie Canal with Miami and Wabash extensions

William Enyeart Sr.'s youngest son Abraham was the probably the first to make the move to Indiana, along with his mother Jane who was living with him by that time. In 1838, he married Jerusha Keller, daughter of Judge John Keller who had moved to Wabash Co., IN in 1828 (Ref 12, p.215, Note 8). By 1840, his sister Margaret and brother Joseph's families had joined them there as well. William and Jane's youngest daughter, Elenor, initially married Eli Maddock of Miami Co., OH in 1841. But when he died just a few years later, she joined her family in Wabash Co., IN and remarried soon after (Note 9). Their older brother Levi also came to IN with his family after his first wife died in 1840. Eventually John and Silas followed too. 

Lagro, Wabash Co., Indiana

In 1848, at the age of 76, Jane (Norris) Enyeart died in Lagro, Indiana. She was the birth mother of 16 children, as well as the step-mother to the 5 living children of William Enyeart Sr.'s first wife Catherine Shell (our direct ancestor). She married a 40 year old man at the age of barely 16, and spent the next 36 years either pregnant or nursing infant children. Then, only 3 years later, she was left a widow to figure out the rest of story on her own. I am not sure what she was like as an actual person. No doubt there were some interesting family dynamics in a situation as complex as this. But I would say she deserves some type of motherhood medal none the less.

Likewise, William Sr., though of dubious character regarding his some of his (and his children's) marital choices, was none the less a well-respected and valuable member of his community. He successfully provided for the household needs of 23 children and two wives. He laid out property provisions for Jane and each of his living children in his will, and secured their futures by arranging marriages for all but the youngest 3 before his death at age 80. Many of these marriages were forged by community ties between men who came to the Juniata River Valley from Franklin Co., MD after serving together in the Revolutionary War. The healthy and fertile offspring of his line have spread the Enyeart clan far a wide across western PA, OH, and IN and it is hard to even imagine how many descendants of his line are still with us today.

Notes

1) According to a history given by Mrs. Racer of Troy, OH in 1913 at the Norris Family Reunion in LaGrange Co., IN, Joseph P. Norris, Sr. actually had two wives; 5 children with the first wife, and 11 with the second. If that is the case, Mary Moody was his second wife. I have not yet been able to find any other indications of a first wife, or other children.

2) Although I did look up some of the actual survey maps for the Deans, Norrises, and Enyearts, for other families I am mainly relying on 1873 Atlas of Huntingdon County that was published by A. Pomeroy & Company of Philadelphia, PA, as well as on accounts of early settlers in Ref 1. Most of the original settler families owned many plots of land by 1873, due to expanding families and business interests, but it was assumed that the original land purchase was either near the river or a city center such as McConnellstown and Marklesburg. Of course, some families may have relocated entirely over time, and without tracing each land transfer, it is not possible to say for certain if that is truly where they resided at that exact point in time (a project for another day!). But is serves to give a rough idea of "the neighborhood" none the less.

3) Following the Revolutionary War, many settlers used their military land bounties to settle in OH, prized for its fertile Ohio River Valley farmland. Getting there would have been very tough coming from where they were in western PA though. The Miami & Erie Canals did not open until the 1820s and the National Road did not reach that part of Ohio until the 1830s, so travel by wagon was probably still not possible. Did they go by foot or horse and leave most everything behind? Tough to say. Definitely the reason so many of them made the trip before marriage and kids though!

4) Supposedly John married there in 1809, though I cannot find any records of him until the 1830 census. The county was created in 1807, however, so it is certainly possible.

5) If you can tell me exactly how they are related, I would be most grateful. As far as I can tell, there are two different Householder lines that settled in the same area, and everything I have read has their various family members incorrectly all tangled up together. One was from Washington Co., MD (likely ours) and the other from Lancaster Co., PA, but which actually offspring go with which, I have no idea.

6) The 1820 census shows that one of their married children was likely living with them, along with 3 of their grandchildren who were under the age of 10. Since only the head of household name is reported on the census until 1850, it is difficult to say who this is, though the ages/sexes do seem to match with William, Jr.'s family at that time. Given William, Jr's issues with money and his young age of death, one wonders if he perhaps had problems with alcohol or gambling as well.

7) They were from Wayne Twp., Mifflin Co., PA originally, which borders Huntingdon Co. on the NE, but moved away to Centre Co., PA for a time. Interestingly, Jonathan has a younger brother named John, born two years after him, who stayed in Centre Co., PA and also married an Elizabeth. Which makes sorting things out between them pretty confusing. Also, sometimes the name is written as Marsden instead.

8) Although I cannot find an actual record, Abraham likely divorced his first wife as well. He had only one child in 1840 with Jerusha Keller, and then remarried to Isabella Hullinger in 1843. Jerusha is not supposed to have died until 1870, however. Again, this was very uncommon at that time. Prior to 1852 in Indiana, divorce was only allowed for one of seven causes: "adultery, matrimonial incapacity, bigamous contract, two years' absence with intent to abandon, desertion and living in adultery, conviction of felony; ...extremely barbarous and inhuman treatment". https://www.repository.law.indiana.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3690&context=ilj : 2023.

9) It is likely that Elenor had her first child out of wedlock as well. Elenor did not marry for the first time until 1841, and then remarried to Thomas Martin in 1845. However, the 1850 census lists an 11 year old son named William Martin born in 1839. According to https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/7806451/william-enyart, William was actually Thomas Martin's step-son rather than son. Elenor and Thomas relocated from IN to Fulton Co., OH after their marriage.

References 

0) Gardner, A. "Courtship, Sex, and the Single Colonist". CW Journal, 2007. https://research.colonialwilliamsburg.org/Foundation/journal/Holiday07/court.cfm : 2023.

1) Africa, J. Simpson. "History of Huntingdon and Blair counties, Pennsylvania". Philadelphia : Louis H. Everts, 1883. https://archive.org/details/historyofhunting00afri/page/n6/mode/1up : 2023.

2) Jordan, John W. "A History of the Juniata Valley and its People v.1". New York : Lewis Historical Publishing Company, 1913. https://www.familysearch.org/library/books/records/item/438262-a-history-of-the-juniata-valley-and-its-people-v-1 : 2023.

3) Jordan, John W. "A History of the Juniata Valley and its People v.3". New York : Lewis Historical Publishing Company, 1913. https://archive.org/details/historyofjuniata03jord/page/1180/mode/2up?view=theater : 2023.

4) Raywalt, James. "The Enyeart Family Newsletter", vol. 2, n.3. Oct 1999. https://freepages.rootsweb.com/~grannyapple/genealogy/ENYART/ENYARTnews05.html :  2023.

5) Carter, William. "A Genealogical and Historical Sketch of William Enyeart and Some of His Descendants". Midland, TX: Self-published, 1964. https://www.familysearch.org/photos/artifacts/22430772?p=47852052&returnLabel=William%20Enyeart%20(LD11-TYV)&returnUrl=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.familysearch.org%2Ftree%2Fperson%2Fmemories%2FLD11-TYV : 2023.

6) Long, W. "History of the Grim Family of Pennsylvania and its Associated Families". Grim Family, Pottsville, Pennsylvania, 1934. https://www.seekingmyroots.com/members/files/G002535.pdf : 2023.

7) "Commemorative Biographical Encyclopedia Of The Juniata Valley". Chambersburg, PA : J.M. Runk & Company, 1897. https://archive.org/details/commemorativebio01cham/page/n9/mode/2up : 2023.

8) Huntingdon Gazette, 7 Feb 1822. "BY an act of Assembly passed the 22nd day of March 1820, directing recovery of principal and interest due to the Commonwealth...authorizing me to to give the Inhabitants of Huntingdon County, Public Notice that an accurate List of all such lands as aforesaid...has been recently put into my hands by the Surveyor General, and that I will attend at the following times and places to receive the name of each owner and occupier of those Lands...March...16th at the House if William Enyeart Junr, Hopewell Township, At 10 o'clock A.M. of each day."

9) "Pennsylvania, U.S., Wills and Probate Records, 1683-1993". Wills, 1787-1908 ; Index to Wills and Letters of Administration, 1787-1918; Author: Huntingdon County (Pennsylvania). Register of Wills; Probate Place: Huntingdon, Pennsylvania. William Enyeart probate on 12 Jun 1828 in Huntingdon, Pennsylvania, USA.

10) "The Canal Era". USHistory.org. https://www.ushistory.org/us/25a.asp#:~:text=The%20Canal%20enabled%20the%20farmers,The%20Erie%20Canal%20transformed%20America. : 2023.

11) Thomas. Huntington Press. http://ingenweb.org/inwabash/town-histories/lagro-early.txt : 2023.

12) Helm, T.B. "History of Wabash County, Indiana : containing a history of the county; its townships, towns, military records portraits of early settlers and prominent men, personal reminiscences, etc.". Chicago : John Morris, Printer, 1884. https://www.familysearch.org/library/books/records/item/178213-history-of-wabash-county-indiana-containing-a-history-of-the-county-its-townships-towns-military-records-portraits-of-early-settlers-and-prominent-men-personal-reminiscences-etc : 2023.